Due to the fact that she was Ari's assistant and Eric's girlfriend, both of the men close to her demand loyalty from her. However, she wanted to stay neutral between the two, keeping business and personal life separate. In the episode of Busey and the Beach, both Eric and Emily have a falling out as the situation of business escalated into harsh feelings. In a later episode in season 1, it was confirmed both broke up and were not on speaking terms.
- Season One: The Review, Talk Show, Date Night, The Script and the Sherpa, Busey and the Beach, New York
- Season Two: Neighbors, Chinatown
- After E and Emily break up, she refers to him as "pizza boy". This is a reference to E's past background as a manager at Sbarro's back in New York.